
News like this is very disheartening...
Thirty-nine states elect judges, and 30 states are holding elections for seats on their highest courts this year. Spending in these races is skyrocketing, with some judges raising $2 million or more for a single campaign. As the amounts rise, questions about whether money is polluting the independence of the judiciary are being fiercely debated across the nation. And nowhere is the battle for judicial seats more ferocious than in Ohio.An examination of the Ohio Supreme Court by The New York Times found that its justices routinely sat on cases after receiving campaign contributions from the parties involved or from groups that filed supporting briefs. On average, they voted in favor of contributors 70 percent of the time. Justice O’Donnell voted for his contributors 91 percent of the time, the highest rate of any justice on the court.
In the 12 years that were studied, the justices almost never disqualified themselves from hearing their contributors’ cases. In the 215 cases with the most direct potential conflicts of interest, justices recused themselves just 9 times.
Even sitting justices have started to question the current system. “I never felt so much like a hooker down by the bus station in any race I’ve ever been in as I did in a judicial race,” said Justice Paul E. Pfeifer, a Republican member of the Ohio Supreme Court. “Everyone interested in contributing has very specific interests.”
i don't know a lot about judicial matters or the campaign issues/funding whatever, but shouldn't this be an ethical issue?
i guess it's really odd to hear there are these blaring contradictions in ethics in a place where standards are supposedly being upheld... [did that make sense?]
Posted by: whitney at October 1, 2006 03:12 PM
yes it should be an ethical issue, but it's money that gets you elected. so it's a situation where there can't be a balance. you just pray that the official has enough decency to rule on law, not special interest money.
Posted by: regan at October 1, 2006 03:54 PM